It’s been two years since MAGGIE CASE (Laura Osnes) left Nashville and came to Piedmount Island, an idyllic wedding spot off the coast of Washington, to take over her grandmother’s photography business, leaving her boyfriend, JAKE COLBY (Scott Michael Foster), and their singing duo Colby & Case behind. Her life is content until Jake’s sister, Jennifer, surprises Maggie by showing up on the island to get married with her brother Jake in tow. Being the wedding photographer, Maggie is thrust into spending time with Jake as she photographs all the pre-wedding events. Jake, who is now a record producer with a big album for recording-star Ashleigh Z in the works, is juggling the pressures of his job and the wedding and soon, Maggie is reminded of his perfectionist personality and know-it-all mentality and why she left him and Nashville behind. Things begin to shift, however, when Maggie and Jake end up singing together at a romantic fire pit cookout and Jennifer convinces them to sing her favorite duet of theirs. “I Belong in Your Arms,” for her first dance. As they rehearse, they begin to see each other in a new light and old patterns start to fall away. They find themselves enjoying spending time with each other at the festivities and even team up to save the day when there is a wedding mishap. And when Jake’s album is suddenly in trouble and may not happen after all, Maggie steps in and helps to save the album even though it will take him out of the country and away from her for over a year. After the ceremony, Jake finds that Maggie’s plan worked, and he must leave immediately and go back to the mainland. But, because the only ferry going back to the mainland is leaving immediately, he is unable to tell Maggie. But while on the ferry, he realizes he’s making a huge mistake leaving Maggie and must find a way to get back to Piedmount Island and her.